Peanut Butter and Burgers, oh yes!
You’d think New York has seen everything by now, but there was a big brouhaha in the local blogosphere when one of the city’s best-loved burger joints, Shake Shack, introduced, for one day only, a Peanut Butter Bacon Burger. “Now,” wrote one blogger, “when someone asks me, ‘what’s the weirdest thing you ever ate?’ that’ll definitely be in the top five.” His verdict, definitely not a rave review, was that it “wasn’t vomit-inducing like I imagined it.”
Here in Tulsa you can get that burger any day of the year at one of OUR best-loved burger joints, Fat Guy’s Burger Bar, and it’s so good it’s worth the trip. In fact you can go Shake Shack one better and order it Thai-style, which comes with grilled pineapple, cilantro, and also that world-famous invention of a penniless Vietnamese immigrant in California, Sriracha. And, if you also ask for triple meat, which I did, you get this.
It was delicious and the peanut butter was the star. Who would have thought that ordinary Peter Pan would mix with the meat and taste just like a Malayan satay sauce?
My only disappointment was the burger. On my last visit, I got the chef to cook it very rare, which required talking to the chef and manager and pleading and begging before they agreed. It was soooo good! One of the best burgers I’ve ever tasted. Read my review to see a photo of it in all its glory. This time I didn’t specify how I wanted it cooked, and so they did it in their regular fashion and it wasn’t nearly as good. Oh it was good, definitely not vomit-inducing, but it wasn’t fabulous… though the peanut butter did bring it close to the fabulous level.
I also got to taste one other thing you normally wouldn’t order at Fat Guy’s. The hot dog.
And that was really really good. So if you’re craving a hot dog it’s a good place to go. I’m sure they’ll put peanut butter on if you ask.


Joey 10:48 am on March 29, 2011 Permalink |
Great review, Brian. I love their PB Thai burger. Unlike you, I prefer mine well done. A tragedy, I know. The Dodge Dog is one of the best things I have ever eaten. I can never finish a whole one.
I love reading your reviews. I can always count on your opinions.
Brian Schwartz 10:49 am on March 29, 2011 Permalink |
I love you Joey! Perhaps I was a bit tough on the well-done burger. I really enjoyed it. And yes that was their Dodge Dog.
LB 4:28 pm on March 29, 2011 Permalink |
Do you know if you are allowed to take their burgers into ONEOK stadium?
Brian Schwartz 6:44 pm on March 29, 2011 Permalink |
Don’t know for sure but I believe that you are. It’s a lot of their business.
Bill 9:15 am on March 30, 2011 Permalink |
Very good review. I gotta try one now!
Tim Epps 12:13 pm on April 27, 2011 Permalink |
I was introduced to the PB burger at the Cherry Cricket in Denver this summer. My creation (also cooked rare) had a breakfast motif with peanut butter, bacon, pepper jack cheese, jalapenos & a fried egg. No condiments required!
Fat Guys comes very close to my design but does not offer the egg. So, I will bring in my own next time to see if they will add it to my burger.