“If you want a steak as good as ours,” the manager told me, “you’d have to go to Peter Luger’s in Brooklyn.” Well I can’t vouch for the truth of that, but I can tell you the steaks at Doe’s are crazy good.
It was my first visit. Somehow, Doe’s was never on my radar. It should be. Stepping inside the building I’d always passed by without a thought, I found this.
Certainly not elegant, but it’s the kind of interior that screams “serious steak!” Most of the older New York steakhouses look like that. Informal, with the wood-accented decor of an old-time bar. Old New York steakhouses are famed for their brusque service, but the waiters here were friendly and helpful. Of course I ordered their steak. I got a one-pound sirloin ($24). Included in the price of the steak is a nice small salad and potatoes. (Your choice of baked, boiled, mashed, French fries or sweet potato fries.) The salad and potatoes are fine, and the bread, which is a fried concoction a lot like a New Orleans beignet. Showing admirable self-control, I had them with honey for dessert. But the steak is the star of the show.
Like all their steaks, it’s been aged 21 days. Perhaps that’s what gave it its incredible rich flavor. As I said, it was crazy good. Sirloin is the worst-quality steak you can get at Doe’s — and the cheapest (the smallest ribeye is $38 and the smallest porterhouse is $42 while you can get a sirloin a bit smaller than mine for $18) — so if the more expensive steaks are even better than the sirloin it just might be true what the manager said.
I just had to get another look at that steak!
Doe’s Eat Place
1350 E. 15th St
585-3637
Open every day except for Sunday at 5:30 PM
Felipe 9:03 am on January 18, 2012 Permalink |
Very excited! Unfortunately I had only eaten there once before they closed. Glad to have another local place reopen!